Judge Crater was an associate justice for the Supreme Court for the State of New York. He got disappeared along with his “girlfriend” Sally Lou Ritz.
Their disappearance has remained a well-kept secret for eighty years . Some speculated the judge ran afoul of the mafia, which is not all that outlandish a prospect, considering that there were any number of judges during that era known to have connections with organized crime.
Others, however, believe the judge and his mistress planned their own disappearance and probably skipped town with bags of loot in an effort to start a new life elsewhere.