The Bar Council of India has told the Delhi High Court that conducting Common Law Admission Test (CLAT) in languages other than English will give opportunities to more aspirants to appear in the exam and pursue a career in law. BCI stated its stand in an affidavit filed in response to a PIL seeking conduct of CLAT 2024 not only in English but also in regional languages.
The Council said it "supports" the issue raised by petitioner Sudhanshu Pathak, a law student at Delhi University. The CLAT examination, which is organised by the Consortium of National Law Universities, is conducted in English and CLAT-2024 is scheduled to take place in December 2023.
According to the PIL, the CLAT (UG) exam "discriminates" against students with regional language-based educational backgrounds and fails to create a "level playing field" for them.
"Bar Council of India supports the issue raised by the petitioner for conducting the CLAT examination in languages other than English as the same will give opportunities to more citizens of the country to appear in the exam and pursue law as a career," the affidavit by the BCI said.
The BCI, in its response, said according to the Legal Education Rules, English has to be the medium of instruction in both the integrated five-year and three-year law courses, but it is open to the institution to allow instruction in any language other than English.
If the medium of instruction of legal education is other than English, students have to take English as a compulsory paper, it added. The BCI also informed that the All India Bar Examination (AIBE) is held in 23 languages, including English, Hindi and other regional languages.
The Consortium of NLUs earlier told the high court that preparedness of the upcoming CLAT-2024 is at an advanced stage and any judicial order compelling the introduction of additional language options this year without any deliberations and studies, would result in serious administrative and operational issues.
The consortium has said it has constituted an expert committee of Vice-Chancellors of five member NLUs to study the issue of offering the CLAT exam in additional languages, besides English, and to prepare a comprehensive roadmap after reviewing stakeholders' viewpoints and potential constraints.
The consortium, in its reply to the petition, said the report of the expert committee will enable it to make suitable advance preparation for conducting CLAT in additional languages in the coming years, after ironing out all anticipated difficulties.
The committee held its first meeting on June 25 and framed certain issues relating to the subject matter, it said.
The petitioner has contended that "in a hyper-competitive paper, they (students from non-English language background) are linguistically disempowered as they have to surpass the additional hurdle of learning and mastering a new language".
The petitioner was represented through senior advocate Jayant Mehta and lawyers Akash Vajpai and Sakshi Raghav.
(With PTI Inputs)
