Italy's decision on marines a diplomatic tragedy: Chandy
New Delhi, Mar 13: Amid anger back home, Kerala Chief Minister Oommen Chandy today met Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to press that the Centre should act to bring back for trial the two Italian marines
New Delhi, Mar 13: Amid anger back home, Kerala Chief Minister Oommen Chandy today met Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to press that the Centre should act to bring back for trial the two Italian marines who are accused of killing two fishermen.
Terming Italy's decision not to send back its marines as a "diplomatic tragedy", he said they should not escape under the garb of diplomatic status and it is the responsibility of the Centre to ensure their return to stand trial here.
Chandy, whose Congress-led UDF government came under attack from Opposition over handling of the issue, was critical of Italy, saying it used diplomacy as a "weapon to cheat" another nation's apex court and "shield" the killers.
"There will be no compromise on this issue. The marines should be tried under Indian law. Diplomatic status should not be used as a weapon to cheat another nation's apex judiciary. It should not be used as a means to shield the killers.
"No nation can agree with it. World will stand by India on this issue. That is why I am telling that Italy's stand on this issue is a diplomatic tragedy," he said.
The chief minister, who also discussed the issue with Congress chief Sonia Gandhi, said it is the time for the Centre to act. He said it is not only Kerala's issue but a question of the country's "prestige and sovereignty".
Asked if it was the Centre's responsibility to bring them back to India, Chandy shot back, "What is the doubt in it?"
Reacting to a question whether the Supreme Court has "erred" in allowing them to go to Italy to cast their votes, he said, "I am not going to find any fault. What next is the specific agenda." He also expressed hope that "Italy will come around and obey Indian laws."
Massimiliano Lattore and Salvatore Girone have been charged with homicide for killing two fishermen off the Kerala coast in February last year. The two were allowed by the apex court on February 22 to travel to Italy for four weeks under the control and custody of the Ambassador of Italy in India, to cast their ballot in the elections scheduled for February 24 and 25.
The court had said that the marines are only allowed to travel to Italy and remain there and will have to return to India.
Chandy said the Prime Minister assured him that all steps would be taken to bring the marines back to India.
"I am sure that the Centre would make all possible efforts to bring them back. That is reflected in Prime Minister's statement in Parliament," he said.
According to Chandy, Italy will have to bow down its head before India and its judiciary.
"Firstly, Italians tried to escape after committing the crime. But our Navy and coast guard managed to arrest them. Secondly, they argued that the marines should be tried under Italian law. But they could not succeed. Now, Italy will have to bow down its head before India and its law."
He said Kerala had opposed the proposal to allow the marines to visit Italy during Christmas and suggested that their family members could join them in the state since the accused had been on bail by that time.
The state had also objected to the bail conditions with the Italian Ambassador as guarantor citing that the envoy could avoid facing legal action in the event of the marines not returning since he enjoyed diplomatic immunity, Chandy said.
The Opposition CPI-M in Kerala had alleged that the central and state governments had played "unfair games" to save the marines.
Mounting its attack on the Congress-led governments, the CPI-M state secretariat had said in a statement that the Centre and the state had hoodwinked the people to ensure a "smooth passage" to the marines to their homes, sacrificing the pride of our country in order to please the Italian government.
"Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Chief Minister Oommen Chandy are now acting like they are innocent. Right from the beginning, the Centre and state were not earnest in the efforts to get the marines punished here," it had said.
Terming Italy's decision not to send back its marines as a "diplomatic tragedy", he said they should not escape under the garb of diplomatic status and it is the responsibility of the Centre to ensure their return to stand trial here.
Chandy, whose Congress-led UDF government came under attack from Opposition over handling of the issue, was critical of Italy, saying it used diplomacy as a "weapon to cheat" another nation's apex court and "shield" the killers.
"There will be no compromise on this issue. The marines should be tried under Indian law. Diplomatic status should not be used as a weapon to cheat another nation's apex judiciary. It should not be used as a means to shield the killers.
"No nation can agree with it. World will stand by India on this issue. That is why I am telling that Italy's stand on this issue is a diplomatic tragedy," he said.
The chief minister, who also discussed the issue with Congress chief Sonia Gandhi, said it is the time for the Centre to act. He said it is not only Kerala's issue but a question of the country's "prestige and sovereignty".
Asked if it was the Centre's responsibility to bring them back to India, Chandy shot back, "What is the doubt in it?"
Reacting to a question whether the Supreme Court has "erred" in allowing them to go to Italy to cast their votes, he said, "I am not going to find any fault. What next is the specific agenda." He also expressed hope that "Italy will come around and obey Indian laws."
Massimiliano Lattore and Salvatore Girone have been charged with homicide for killing two fishermen off the Kerala coast in February last year. The two were allowed by the apex court on February 22 to travel to Italy for four weeks under the control and custody of the Ambassador of Italy in India, to cast their ballot in the elections scheduled for February 24 and 25.
The court had said that the marines are only allowed to travel to Italy and remain there and will have to return to India.
Chandy said the Prime Minister assured him that all steps would be taken to bring the marines back to India.
"I am sure that the Centre would make all possible efforts to bring them back. That is reflected in Prime Minister's statement in Parliament," he said.
According to Chandy, Italy will have to bow down its head before India and its judiciary.
"Firstly, Italians tried to escape after committing the crime. But our Navy and coast guard managed to arrest them. Secondly, they argued that the marines should be tried under Italian law. But they could not succeed. Now, Italy will have to bow down its head before India and its law."
He said Kerala had opposed the proposal to allow the marines to visit Italy during Christmas and suggested that their family members could join them in the state since the accused had been on bail by that time.
The state had also objected to the bail conditions with the Italian Ambassador as guarantor citing that the envoy could avoid facing legal action in the event of the marines not returning since he enjoyed diplomatic immunity, Chandy said.
The Opposition CPI-M in Kerala had alleged that the central and state governments had played "unfair games" to save the marines.
Mounting its attack on the Congress-led governments, the CPI-M state secretariat had said in a statement that the Centre and the state had hoodwinked the people to ensure a "smooth passage" to the marines to their homes, sacrificing the pride of our country in order to please the Italian government.
"Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Chief Minister Oommen Chandy are now acting like they are innocent. Right from the beginning, the Centre and state were not earnest in the efforts to get the marines punished here," it had said.