Subbarao Kept Chidambaram In Loop About 2G Spectrum
New Delhi, Sept 24: The Pioneer on Saturday reported that RBI Governor and former Finance Secretary D Subbarao had regularly appraised the then Finance Minister P chidambaram about the 2G spectrum allocation issue.Though the Centre
New Delhi, Sept 24: The Pioneer on Saturday reported that RBI Governor and former Finance Secretary D Subbarao had regularly appraised the then Finance Minister P chidambaram about the 2G spectrum allocation issue.Though the Centre and the Congress may be defending Chidambaram, but facts point otherwise.
Former Finance Secretary D Subbarao's deposition before the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) on February 3, 2011, clearly shows that he had “fairly and regularly” appraised the then Finance Minister about former Telecom Minister A Raja's move to allot spectrum at seven-year-old price without auction.
The Pioneer reported that on being grilled by the MPs in PAC on his communication and meeting with Chidambaram during the scam period, Subbarao told the PAC: “There were several consultations with the Finance Minister (Chidambaram) at several stages. So, I cannot recall exactly whether this particular letter (November 29, 2007 from DoT) was discussed on a stand-alone basis or together with other developments in the telecom sector, but I do recall that in that period (October 2007 onwards), I was discussing with the Finance Minister, fairly regularly on telecom sector issues.”
Subbarao was responding to the volley of questions from several members of the PAC, on how his directive of November 22, 2007 — to stay the allotment of spectrum and GSM licences to Reliance Communication and Tata Teleservices at 2001 price — was not adhered to.The directive had also sought to find new market-based price for spectrum, and suggested auction.
But on November 29, 2007, DoT wrote to Subbarao that they were going by the 2003 Cabinet approval for the spectrum allotment policy. After the DoT reply, the Finance Ministry kept quiet.
To the questions, whether he had consulted Chidambaram, the former Finance Secretary, who is currently the Reserve Bank Governor, reiterated: “On this letter of November 29 from the Telecom Secretary, I cannot specifically say that I had taken this particular letter to the FM, but I certainly was discussing with him on a regular basis.”
The recent note by the Finance Ministry to the PMO, and minutes of Raja and Chidambaram's meeting, clearly show how Subbarao was overruled by Chidambaram to favour Raja's controversial 2G spectrum allotment.These documents also substantiate Subbarao's deposition before the PAC that Chidambaram was in the loop.
When Subbarao was pressed by MPs, to provide evidence about his communication and meeting with Chidambaram, he told the members and PAC Chairman Murli Manohar Joshi, “Sir, there may not be a paper trail, but there was certainly discussion going on. Sir, as you know — you have been a Minister yourself in the Government — not everything is on paper or reduced to writing. Maybe there were some file endorsements, but I cannot recall them because the note file is not here.”
To a question, whether he brought the violations and difference of opinion to the notice of the Cabinet Secretary or Chidambaram, Subbarao deposed, “I do not recall having said specifically that we should go back to the Cabinet. That I cannot really say without seeing the file. But I should have briefed the Finance Minister about the ongoing discussions.”
Indicating pressure from Chidambaram and Raja, why no auction of spectrum took place, even after he specifically suggested auction, Subbarao said: “…We (Government) were always arguing on the basis of level playing field rather than on the basis of any growth dimensions that might have subsidised. And if they (Ministers) have chosen so, then as a civil servant, I could not contest that.”